« News from Italy - USA | Main | Parabolas y protestas »


You ask if the bare bones are enough: to merit being called a work on a historical event, they are enough.

Do they capture the "soul" of the event? No. That's what the writer is expected to put in. Some writers do so, giving their audience the clear signal that the soul they are placing is what they thought vivified the actual historical event, meaning they had taken time out to do research. Others do so, saying that they are giving a personal interpretation of the event, meaning they did not bother to do much research. Still others do so, being deliberately irreverent or playful with history.

The "soul" of the historical event as depicted by a writer would be above all in the motivations of the characters and the explanation of why certain events happened as they did (characterization, minor characters added, incidental events).

Thank you for the clear points.

I understand then that you have to include the "persons" involved, the "when" and the "where". But is that enough?

Two weeks ago, A.O. Scott, from The New York Times, made a list of the films about Jesus Christ that have been produced since "King of Kings" (Nicholas Ray 1961) until "The Passion of the Christ" (Mel Gibson, 2004). I've not seen all of them, but as far as I know, some are not so recommendable, because they don't "do justice" to the drama of love that the Life, Passion, Death and Resurrection of the Lord has been.

Do the "bare bones" have something to do with the "soul" of the event? If so, where does it lie? (if the soul "lies" somewhere). In other words, where do I have to look at with attention to discover the sense of the facts and its representation?"

The comments to this entry are closed.

Pontificia Università della Santa Croce

  • apollinare1

    Facoltà di Comunicazione Istituzionale
    Palazzo di Sant'Apollinare
    Piazza di Sant'Apollinare n. 49
    00186 Roma

    PUSC HomeFCI Home

P&C Project:
Experts in humanity

  • The Poetics and Christianity Project is an international forum for studiyng the intersection of artistic culture and expressions of religious faith, with a special emphasis on narrative and dramatic arts. It offers a meeting place for scholars and artist of diverse fields of expertise.

    * * *
    “ For tragedy is an imitation ('mimesis'), not of men, but of an action ('praxeos') and of life, and life consists in action, and its end is a mode of action ('to telos praxeis tis estin'), not a quality. Now character determines men's qualities, but it is by their actions that they are happy or the reverse.”

    [Aristotle’s Poetics, 50 a 16-18]

    “ There is a need for heralds of the Gospel who are experts in humanity, who have a profound knowledge of the heart of present-day man, sharing his joys and hopes, his anguish and sadness, and who are also contemplative souls, in love with God. “

    [Pope John Paul II to the European Council of Bishops' Conferences, 11-10-85]


  • Posts and Comments are here written in English, Italian, Spanish and French.

    Feel free to use anyone of those Languages in writing. Almost everyone of us can read them.

    Our multilingual online work is not a presage of the confusion in a new Tower of Babel.

    The purpose is just the opposite, working on "Poetics & Christianity". Enjoy your stay.


  • powered-long.gif
Blog powered by Typepad
Member since 08/2003